Sometimes. A rental pays only if rent covers every cost: mortgage, taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs, big replacements and management. Many barely break even monthly and land near an index fund over 10 years, with more work and risk. Consider one only after Ladder step 7, with a separate reserve.
Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.
Subscribe to the channelQuentin is 41 and earns $95,000 a year. He has no debt except his mortgage, six months of expenses in savings, and 15% of his pay going into his 401(k). He also has $56,000 sitting in a brokerage account, and a coworker keeps telling him the same thing: “Buy a rental. Tenants pay off your mortgage. It’s passive income.”
A three-bedroom house across town is listed at $200,000 and would rent for about $1,750 a month, more than the mortgage. Money machine, right?
Here’s the short answer. A rental can be a good investment, but only if the rent covers every cost, not just the mortgage: taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs, big replacements and management. Run those numbers and many rentals barely break even, landing close to an index fund over time with far more work. Being a landlord is worth it when you buy at the right price, keep a separate cash reserve and actually want the job. It belongs on step 7 of the Middle Money Ladder or later, never before.
What does a rental property really cost each month?
Most people compare rent to the mortgage and stop. Here’s the full list. He’s putting 25% down ($50,000) plus about $6,000 in closing costs, and borrowing $150,000 at an example rate of 7.5% for 30 years.
| Monthly item | Amount | How we got it |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | $1,750 | Market rent estimate |
| Mortgage (principal and interest) | -$1,049 | $150,000, 7.5%, 30 years |
| Property tax | -$167 | Example: 1% of price a year |
| Landlord insurance | -$150 | Example: $1,800 a year |
| Vacancy | -$123 | 7% of rent |
| Repairs and maintenance | -$140 | Example: 8% of rent |
| Capital expenses (roof, HVAC, water heater) | -$140 | Example: 8% of rent |
| Property management | -$140 | Example: 8% of rent |
| Cash flow | -$158 | Every month, out of his pocket |
Why 7% for vacancy? The Census Bureau put the national rental vacancy rate at 7.3% in the second quarter of 2026. Your street may differ, but zero is never the right number.
“Capital expenses” are the big, rare ones: roof, furnace, water heater, appliances. They all break eventually. Setting money aside monthly is how you avoid putting a new roof on a credit card. In our video on how much house you can afford, a $7,000 air conditioner failure in month 13 wipes out a homeowner’s emergency fund.
If Quentin manages it himself, his cash flow is about -$18 a month, and he gets the 11 p.m. call about the leaking toilet.
So what: rent that “covers the mortgage” can still lose money every month.
What is the 1% rule for rental property?
The 1% rule is a quick screen many real estate investors use (it’s their rule of thumb, not ours): monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. A $200,000 house should rent for $2,000 or more.
Quentin’s house rents for $1,750, or 0.875%. It fails the screen, and the table above shows why: at that rent, the costs eat everything. The 1% rule is a filter for which listings deserve a full calculation, not a substitute for one.
How do you calculate the cap rate?
The cap rate tells you what a property earns before any mortgage, so you can compare it to other investments on equal footing.
Cap rate = net operating income / purchase price. Net operating income (NOI) is the rent minus every operating cost except the mortgage.
Quentin’s numbers: $1,750 rent minus $859 a month in taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs, capital expenses and management leaves $891 a month, or $10,690 a year. Divide by $200,000 and the cap rate is about 5.3%.
Now compare that to his loan. He’s borrowing at 7.5% to buy something that earns 5.3% before financing. When the cap rate is below your mortgage rate, borrowing makes the cash flow worse, not better. That’s exactly why his cash flow is negative. His “cash-on-cash” return (yearly cash flow divided by the $56,000 he put in) is about -3.4% in year one.
So what: look for a cap rate comfortably above your mortgage rate if you want the property to pay you every month.
Is a rental property a better investment than index funds?
Cash flow isn’t the whole story. A rental also builds wealth through the tenant paying down your loan and through the home’s value rising. So let’s look at 10 years, with rents and costs rising 3% a year and the house sold at the end with 6% in selling costs. These are example assumptions, not predictions.
| 10-year result for Quentin’s $56,000 | What he walks away with |
|---|---|
| Rental, home value grows 2% a year | About $90,200 |
| Rental, home value grows 3% a year | About $119,200 |
| Rental, 3% growth, he manages it himself | About $138,400 |
| Index fund, example 6% return | About $101,900 |
| Index fund, example 8% return | About $124,300 |
The rental rows are his sale proceeds after paying off the loan (about $130,200 by then), minus the cash he fed the property. All rows are before taxes.
What the table shows: the rental only clearly wins when the home appreciates well and Quentin does the management himself. That extra $19,000 or so is real, but it’s wages for 10 years of tenant screening, repairs and phone calls, not passive income.
And the table can’t show risk. The index fund holds hundreds of companies; the rental is one house. One bad tenant or foundation problem can erase years of gains. You can sell a fund in a day; a house takes months.
So what: a rental is a part-time business that comes with an investment attached. If you’d rather not run a business, a low-cost index fund does a lot of the same work. Our walk through all nine Ladder steps lands on the same simple tool for step 7: about 15% of income into a 401(k) or IRA, using low-cost index funds. Our guide on how to start investing covers that route.
Is house hacking a smarter way to start?
House hacking means buying a small multi-unit home, living in one unit and renting the others. Because it’s your own home, you can use owner-occupant financing. HUD says FHA loans are available on 1 to 4 unit properties with as little as 3.5% down.
Percival, 29, earns $70,000 (about $4,606 a month take-home by our estimate; check your pay stub). He’s looking at a $280,000 duplex with 3.5% down. With the 1.75% upfront FHA premium rolled in and an example 6.5% rate, his principal and interest is about $1,738. Add about $124 of monthly FHA mortgage insurance, $233 of property tax and $200 of insurance, and the total is about $2,295.
The other unit rents for $1,300. Percival’s share drops to about $995 a month, roughly 22% of his take-home, under our 25% target for housing. That’s a real win.
Now the stress test. If the other unit sits empty, he owes the full $2,295, about 50% of take-home, far past our one-third red line. He needs a reserve to survive empty months. And with 3.5% down, that FHA insurance lasts for the life of the loan (our post on how to get rid of PMI explains the FHA rules).
What are the tax rules for landlords?
Taxes are a real advantage, and a source of surprises. The basics, from IRS Publication 527:
- You report rent and expenses on Schedule E. Mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, repairs and management fees are generally deductible.
- Repairs and improvements are different. Fixing a broken window is a repair you deduct that year. A new roof is an improvement you depreciate over time.
- Depreciation. Residential rental buildings are depreciated over 27.5 years. Land isn’t depreciated. If $160,000 of Quentin’s price is the building, that’s about $5,818 a year he can deduct even though he didn’t spend it, which often wipes out the taxable profit on a small rental.
- The loss limit. If you actively manage the rental, you can deduct up to $25,000 of rental losses against other income, but that allowance shrinks once your modified AGI passes $100,000 and is gone at $150,000.
- Depreciation comes back when you sell. Gain tied to depreciation (unrecaptured section 1250 gain) is taxed at up to 25%, per the IRS.
Landlording also comes with legal duties. The Fair Housing Act bans discrimination in renting, and your state sets rules on deposits, repairs and evictions. Once you own a rental, a tax pro is money well spent; that’s step 8 of the Ladder.
When does being a landlord make sense on the Ladder?
Here’s the order. Don’t skip a step. As our first podcast episode puts it, investing before the early steps is like building the second floor of a house before the foundation is dry.
- No debt except your mortgage (step 5). A rental with credit card debt in the background is a stress machine.
- A full 3 to 6 month cushion for your own household (step 6). See how much should be in your emergency fund.
- Retirement investing on track (step 7), about 15% of income. A rental is an addition to retirement saving, not a replacement for it.
- A separate rental reserve on top of your cushion. A sensible start is six months of the property’s full costs. For Quentin that’s about $11,400, so the real price of entry is about $67,000 in cash, not $56,000.
- A deal that works on paper with honest vacancy, repair and capital expense numbers, and a cap rate you’re happy with.
Common mistakes
- Counting only the mortgage. Vacancy, repairs and capital expenses are real costs, even in the months nothing breaks.
- Assuming you’ll never pay a manager. If you move, get sick or burn out, you’ll need one.
- No reserve. One $6,000 repair should be annoying, not a crisis.
- Buying on appreciation alone. If the deal only works when prices rise fast, it’s a bet, not an investment.
What to do this week
- Check where you are on the Ladder. If you have debt besides your mortgage or less than a full cushion, park the rental idea and work the step you’re on.
- Pick one real listing near you and fill in the full cost table above: mortgage, tax, insurance quote, 7% vacancy, repairs, capital expenses and management.
- Calculate its cap rate and compare it to your likely mortgage rate. Run the payment in our mortgage calculator.
- Add up your true cash needed: down payment, closing costs and a six-month rental reserve.
- Compare the result to the same cash invested at an example 6% and 8% for 10 years.
- Ask a landlord you know about their worst year, not their best.
One money decision, one number worth knowing, one mindset shift. Free, every week.
Frequently asked questions
How much money do you need to buy your first rental property?
Plan for the down payment, closing costs and a separate reserve. In our example, a $200,000 rental with 25% down took $50,000 down, about $6,000 in closing costs and about $11,400 in reserve, roughly $67,000 in total. Your own numbers depend on the price, the loan terms and your lender.
What is a good cash flow on a rental property?
Positive after every cost, including vacancy, repairs, capital expenses and management, not just after the mortgage. A property that’s only positive when you leave those out is really losing money.
What is a good cap rate for a rental?
There’s no single number, since it varies by market and property. A useful test is to compare it to your mortgage rate. If the cap rate is below the rate you’re borrowing at, the loan makes your cash flow worse; Quentin’s 5.3% cap rate against a 7.5% loan is why his cash flow is negative.
Is rental income passive income?
For taxes, rental activity is generally treated as passive, with special rules for owners who actively manage. In real life, it’s rarely hands-off unless you pay a manager, and that fee comes out of your return.
Should I pay off my house or buy a rental property?
Follow the Ladder first: no other debt, a full cushion and about 15% going to retirement. After that, it’s a choice between a guaranteed return (your mortgage rate) and a riskier, more hands-on one. If a rental’s numbers don’t clearly beat your mortgage rate after every cost, paying down your own home or investing in index funds is the simpler path.
Keep reading
- Rent vs. buy: how to decide with real numbers
- How to start investing with little money
- Do you actually need a financial advisor?
Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.
