In the first 24 hours: call the fraud departments of the accounts that were hit, freeze your credit at all three bureaus (free by law), report it at IdentityTheft.gov for a free FTC recovery plan, and change your email and bank passwords. You don’t need to pay anyone for any of it.
Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.
Subscribe to the channelNico is 33 and makes $65,000 a year running the night shift at a distribution center. At 10:40 on a Tuesday night, two things hit his phone a minute apart. An email: “Welcome! Your new store credit card is approved.” Then a text from his bank: “Did you make a $1,240 purchase at an electronics store?”
He didn’t apply for a store card. He was at work. His first instinct was to buy whatever “identity theft protection” came up first online.
Here’s the short answer. In the first 24 hours, do four things, in this order: call the fraud departments of the accounts that were hit, freeze your credit at all three bureaus (free by federal law), report it at IdentityTheft.gov to get the FTC’s free recovery plan, and change the passwords on your email and money accounts. You don’t need to pay anyone to do any of this. The free tools are the real tools.
What should you do first if your identity is stolen?
Stop the bleeding first. Call the companies where something actually happened. For Nico, that’s his bank and the store card issuer.
The FTC’s recovery steps say to call each fraud department, explain that someone stole your identity, ask them to close or freeze the accounts, and change your logins, passwords and PINs. Use the number on the back of your card or the company’s official website, never one from the alert itself. Scammers send fake alerts too.
Speed matters most on a debit card, because that’s your actual cash. Here’s how the FTC explains your maximum loss under federal law:
| Card type and when you report | Most you can lose |
|---|---|
| Credit card, unauthorized charges | $50 |
| Debit card, reported before anyone uses it | $0 |
| Debit card, reported within 2 business days of learning about it | $50 |
| Debit card, reported after 2 business days but within 60 days of the statement | $500 |
| Debit card, reported more than 60 days after the statement | Possibly all of it |
Nico called his bank at 10:50 p.m. Because he reported it the same night, the most the law lets him lose on that $1,240 charge is $50.
So what: the first hour is about phone calls, not paperwork. Every day you wait on a debit card can cost you real money.
How do you freeze your credit?
A credit freeze stops new accounts from being opened in your name, because lenders can’t pull your credit report while it’s frozen. It’s the single strongest thing you can do, and it’s free. Since September 21, 2018, federal law makes freezing and unfreezing your credit free at all three nationwide bureaus.
How it works:
- Contact all three bureaus: Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. A freeze at one doesn’t carry over.
- Online or by phone, it’s fast. The bureau must place the freeze within one business day. By mail, within three business days.
- Lifting it is fast too. A lift requested online or by phone must happen within one hour.
- It lasts until you lift it, and it doesn’t affect your credit score, according to the FTC.
- Applying for credit later? Lift only the bureau the lender uses, then refreeze.
Type each bureau’s address yourself, and save the login or PIN each one gives you. You’ll need it to lift the freeze later.
Nico froze all three from his phone on his break, for $0.
So what: a freeze doesn’t undo what already happened, but it slams the door on the next fake account. Do all three tonight.
Fraud alert vs. credit freeze: which one do you need?
A fraud alert doesn’t block anyone from seeing your report. It tells lenders to verify your identity before they open new credit. Here’s how they compare, based on the FTC’s guide to freezes and fraud alerts:
| Credit freeze | Initial fraud alert | Extended fraud alert | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it does | Blocks access to your report for new credit | Lenders must verify it’s you | Lenders must verify it’s you |
| Cost | Free | Free | Free |
| How long | Until you lift it | 1 year, renewable | 7 years |
| Who you contact | All three bureaus | One bureau (it tells the other two) | One bureau (it tells the other two) |
| Who can get it | Anyone | Anyone | Identity theft victims with an FTC Identity Theft Report or police report |
If your identity has actually been stolen, the FTC suggests placing a fraud alert even if you already have a freeze. The freeze blocks; the alert adds a second check.
So what: if something has already happened, do both. If you just got a data breach letter and nothing’s been misused yet, a freeze alone is usually the stronger move.
How do you report identity theft to the FTC?
Go to IdentityTheft.gov (or call 1-877-438-4338). You answer questions about what happened, and the site builds two things for you: an official FTC Identity Theft Report and a personal recovery plan with your next steps. If you create an account, it tracks your progress and pre-fills letters to businesses and credit bureaus. If you don’t, print and save the report and plan right away, because you can’t get back to them once you leave the page.
That report is your proof. You’ll use it to close fake accounts, block fake information on your credit reports and get the 7-year extended fraud alert. The FTC also suggests filing a police report.
You’re not alone in this. The FTC says that in 2024, there were more than 1.1 million reports of identity theft made through IdentityTheft.gov.
Then pull your credit reports. You can check your report from each bureau for free every week at AnnualCreditReport.com, a program the FTC confirms is now permanent. Nico found the store card plus a second application he hadn’t seen yet.
So what: the FTC report turns “I swear that wasn’t me” into a document businesses have to take seriously. Get it on day one.
What is tax identity theft, and how do you stop it?
Tax identity theft is when someone uses your Social Security number to file a return and grab a refund, or to get a job. You often find out when your own return gets rejected. The IRS lists other warning signs, including a W-2 or 1099 from an employer you never worked for, a notice about unemployment benefits you never applied for, or an unreported income notice.
If that happens, follow the IRS letter’s instructions and keep filing as usual. You generally don’t need the IRS affidavit (Form 14039) if you already reported through IdentityTheft.gov or the IRS already sent you a letter.
The best prevention is an Identity Protection PIN. It’s a six-digit number, known only to you and the IRS, that prevents someone else from filing a tax return with your Social Security number. According to the IRS:
- Anyone with an SSN or ITIN who can verify their identity can get one.
- The fastest way is through your IRS online account.
- It’s valid for one calendar year. A new one is generated every year, so you’ll need the current one each time you file.
So what: an IP PIN is free and takes a few minutes online. Once your SSN is out there, it’s the lock on your tax refund. If you already have a surprise tax bill, our post on why you owe taxes this year walks through the normal reasons first.
How do you know if your information was in a data breach?
Usually the company tells you, in a notice that says what was exposed. Confirm it on the company’s real website, not through a link in the email.
What you do depends on what leaked. The FTC’s data breach steps cover each case. In short:
- Password leaked: change it on that site and anywhere you reused it.
- Card number leaked: ask the card issuer for a new number and watch your statements.
- Social Security number leaked: freeze your credit at all three bureaus, pull your free reports, and get an IRS IP PIN.
- The company offers free credit monitoring: the FTC says to take advantage of it. Free is the right price.
So what: you can’t control who gets breached. You can make sure a leaked number doesn’t turn into a new account.
Is identity theft protection worth it?
Run the math before you buy. Paid services mostly bundle three things: monitoring, recovery help and insurance. The FTC’s guide to these services points out what each really does:
- Monitoring alerts you after your information shows up somewhere. It doesn’t prevent anything, and most services won’t flag things like tax refund fraud or benefits fraud.
- Recovery help gives you a case manager. IdentityTheft.gov gives you the plan and the pre-filled letters for free.
- Insurance may cover costs of reclaiming your identity, lost wages and legal fees. It generally won’t reimburse money scammers stole.
Now the money. Say a service costs an example $15 a month. That’s $180 a year, or $1,800 over 10 years. A freeze, a fraud alert, weekly credit reports and an IP PIN cost $0.
If that $15 a month went into a retirement account instead, once you reach step 7, at an example 7% return, it would grow to about $2,600 in 10 years. That’s the real price of paying for what’s already free.
Paying can make sense if you’ve been hit hard and want someone else to make the calls. First ask what’s covered, what the deductible is, and whether your renters policy, employer or a breach notice already gives you coverage.
So what: for most people, the free freeze plus a little attention beats a monthly fee. Spend that money on the Middle Money Ladder instead. Our podcast overview of the Ladder walks through all nine steps.
Why your money “numbers page” is your best defense
Fraud is easier to spot when you know what’s supposed to be there. That’s step 1 of the Middle Money Ladder: know your numbers. Your one-page list of every account and debt doubles as a fraud checklist. Our podcast on knowing your numbers walks through building it from your last three statements, line by line, because you can’t change something you can’t see.
It’s also why a cash cushion matters. Even when the law limits your loss, getting debit card money back can take days. Nico’s $1,240 was gone from checking for a few days, right before rent. His $2,000 starter cushion, kept in a separate account, covered the gap. As our video on the $2,000 starter cushion puts it, the cushion turns a disaster back into an inconvenience. If you don’t have one yet, start there; our guide to how much emergency fund you need covers the full target.
Still building your credit file? A freeze doesn’t stop that. See our guide to building credit from scratch.
So what: a list of your accounts tells you what’s fake, and a cushion buys you time while the bank sorts it out.
What to do this week
- Tonight: call the fraud department of every account that was hit, using the number on your card or the official website. Change your email password first, then your bank passwords.
- Tonight: freeze your credit at Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Save the PINs or logins somewhere safe.
- Tomorrow: place a fraud alert with one bureau, then file your report at IdentityTheft.gov and save the report and recovery plan.
- This week: pull all three credit reports for free and list every account or inquiry you don’t recognize. Follow the recovery plan for each one.
- This week: get an IRS Identity Protection PIN through your IRS online account.
- This weekend: update your one-page list of accounts and make sure your $2,000 starter cushion (or full emergency fund) sits in a separate account.
One money decision, one number worth knowing, one mindset shift. Free, every week.
Frequently asked questions
Does freezing your credit hurt your credit score?
No. The FTC says placing or lifting a freeze doesn’t affect your score. A freeze mainly affects new credit: the CFPB says creditors on accounts you already have can still see your file, and so can you.
Can I freeze my child’s credit?
Yes. Parents and guardians can freeze the credit file of a child under 16 for free, and the bureaus will create a file just to freeze it if one doesn’t exist, according to the FTC. You’ll need proof you’re the parent or guardian, like a birth certificate.
Do I need a police report for identity theft?
Not always. The FTC Identity Theft Report from IdentityTheft.gov is what most businesses and credit bureaus ask for. The FTC still suggests filing a police report too, and some companies require one, so bring your FTC report, a photo ID and proof of address.
Can I get a new Social Security number after identity theft?
Usually not. In most cases you can’t get a new number without evidence that someone is actively misusing it, according to the FTC’s data breach guidance. A freeze, a fraud alert and an IRS IP PIN protect the number you have.
Keep reading
- How to Track Your Spending (and Find Your Net Worth) in One Evening
- How Many Bank Accounts Should You Have? The Simple Setup That Works
- How Banks Make Money Off You (and How to Keep More of It)
Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.
