Big Decisions

High-Deductible Plan With an HSA vs. a PPO: Which Costs You Less?

By · Updated November 20, 2026
The short answer

Compare total yearly cost, not premiums: premiums + expected out-of-pocket, minus employer HSA money, minus the tax you save on your HSA contributions. Run a normal year and a bad year. If the HDHP wins but you can’t cover its deductible from savings, the PPO may be safer for now.

Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.

Subscribe to the channel

Rhea is 29, earns $62,000, and has open enrollment due Friday. Her job offers two health plans. The PPO costs her $120 a month. The high-deductible plan costs $40 a month and comes with an HSA, plus $500 a year from her employer.

Cheaper sounds better. But the deductible on the cheap plan is $2,000, and her friend told her “you’ll get killed if anything happens.” So she does what most people do: she picks the same plan as last year and hopes.

The short answer: add up each plan’s total yearly cost, not just the premium. The formula is: premiums + the out-of-pocket costs you expect, minus any employer HSA money, minus the tax you save on your own HSA contributions. Run it twice, once for a normal year and once for a bad year where you hit the out-of-pocket maximum. The plan that wins both is your answer. If the high-deductible plan wins on cost but you couldn’t cover its deductible from savings today, the PPO may be the safer pick for now.

The one formula that compares any two plans

Premiums get all the attention because you see them every paycheck. As our video on what to do with a raise puts it, a broke mind sees monthly payments and a rich mind sees totals. But your real yearly cost has four pieces:

  1. Premiums: what comes out of your paycheck, times 12.
  2. Expected out-of-pocket: deductible, copays and coinsurance for the care you think you’ll use.
  3. Minus employer HSA money: cash your employer puts in your account. It’s yours, and it pays medical bills.
  4. Minus your tax savings: the taxes you don’t pay on what you put into the HSA yourself.

So: yearly cost = premiums + expected out-of-pocket − employer HSA contribution − tax savings on your HSA contribution.

The money you put into the HSA isn’t a cost. It’s still yours. Only the tax break counts. So what: with four numbers per plan, “cheap plan vs good plan” becomes simple subtraction.

What makes a plan HSA-eligible, and why the HSA matters

You can only open and contribute to an HSA if you’re covered by a qualifying high-deductible health plan (HDHP) and don’t have other disqualifying coverage. For 2026, the IRS sets these rules in Revenue Procedure 2025-19:

2026 IRS limit Self-only coverage Family coverage
Minimum HDHP deductible $1,700 $3,400
Maximum out-of-pocket (not counting premiums) $8,500 $17,000
HSA contribution limit (you + employer combined) $4,400 $8,750
Extra catch-up if you’re 55 or older +$1,000 +$1,000

One detail people miss: the limit includes your employer’s deposit, according to IRS Publication 969. If your employer puts in $500 on a self-only plan, you can add up to $3,900.

What makes the HSA special is the triple tax advantage described in Publication 969:

  • Contributions go in tax-free. Through payroll, they skip federal income tax, and the IRS’s Publication 15-B (2026) says they also skip Social Security and Medicare tax.
  • Growth is tax-free. Interest and investment earnings inside the account aren’t taxed.
  • Withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free.

And the money rolls over. Unused HSA dollars carry into next year and stay with you if you change jobs. A health FSA, by contrast, is generally “use-it-or-lose-it,” per Publication 969 (some plans allow a small carryover or grace period). So what: an HSA isn’t a coupon that expires in December.

Worked example 1: Rhea, healthy and single

Here are Rhea’s two plans. These are example numbers. Your plan documents will be different, so swap in your own.

  • PPO: $120 a month, $1,000 deductible, $4,000 out-of-pocket max, $30 doctor visits, $10 prescriptions.
  • HDHP: $40 a month, $2,000 deductible, $5,000 out-of-pocket max, $500 employer HSA deposit.

Rhea plans to put $1,500 of her own money into the HSA. At $62,000, her taxable income after the standard deduction is $45,900, which puts her in the 12% federal bracket. Add 7.65% for Social Security and Medicare and our usual 4% estimate for state and local tax, and each HSA dollar saves her about 23.65 cents. On $1,500, that’s $355.

A normal year for Rhea is three doctor visits and one monthly generic prescription. On the PPO, that’s 3 × $30 plus 12 × $10 = $210 in copays. On the HDHP she pays the full negotiated price until she reaches the deductible, so say 3 × $150 plus 12 × $15 = $630. The bad year: an injury that sends her to the out-of-pocket max on either plan.

Rhea (single) PPO, normal year HDHP, normal year PPO, bad year HDHP, bad year
Premiums $1,440 $480 $1,440 $480
Out-of-pocket $210 $630 $4,000 $5,000
Employer HSA money $0 −$500 $0 −$500
Tax savings on $1,500 $0 −$355 $0 −$355
Total yearly cost $1,650 $255 $5,440 $4,625

The HDHP wins both years: by $1,395 in a normal year and by $815 even in a terrible one. And in the normal year, she ends December with $1,370 still in her HSA ($1,500 + $500 − $630), which rolls into next year.

Why does it win the bad year too? Quick shortcut: the HDHP’s max is $1,000 higher, but she saves $960 in premiums ($80 a month) and gets $500 from her employer. That’s a $1,460 head start against a $1,000 worst-case gap. So what: when premium savings plus employer money beat the gap in out-of-pocket maximums, the HDHP wins no matter how the year goes.

Worked example 2: Ruben’s family, which hits the deductible

Ruben is 38, married with two kids, and the household earns $95,000. Filing jointly, their taxable income after the standard deduction is $62,800, also in the 12% bracket, so the same 23.65% tax savings applies. Their kids are active, one has allergies, and they reliably burn through about $6,000 of medical care a year at the plan’s negotiated prices.

  • PPO: $380 a month, $1,500 family deductible, then 20% coinsurance, $6,000 out-of-pocket max.
  • HDHP: $300 a month, $4,000 family deductible, then 20% coinsurance, $9,000 out-of-pocket max, $750 employer HSA deposit.

Ruben plans to put $4,000 into the HSA so the deductible is covered. Tax savings: $4,000 × 23.65% = $946.

On $6,000 of care, the PPO costs them the $1,500 deductible plus 20% of the next $4,500, or $2,400. The HDHP costs the $4,000 deductible plus 20% of the last $2,000, or $4,400. The bad year: a surgery that maxes out both plans.

Ruben’s family PPO, normal year HDHP, normal year PPO, bad year HDHP, bad year
Premiums $4,560 $3,600 $4,560 $3,600
Out-of-pocket $2,400 $4,400 $6,000 $9,000
Employer HSA money $0 −$750 $0 −$750
Tax savings on $4,000 $0 −$946 $0 −$946
Total yearly cost $6,960 $6,304 $10,560 $10,904

This one is close. The HDHP saves $656 in a normal year. In a bad year, the PPO saves $344. Running the numbers in between, the PPO only pulls ahead once the family uses about $27,000 of care in a year.

The shortcut tells the same story: premium savings ($960) plus employer money ($750) is $1,710, against a $3,000 gap in out-of-pocket maximums. The HDHP has to lean on the tax break to stay close.

And that tax break is a lever. If Ruben’s family contributed $8,000 (the family limit of $8,750 minus the employer’s $750), their tax savings would be $1,892 and the HDHP’s bad-year total would drop to $9,958, beating the PPO by $602. But only if they actually have $8,000 to put in. So what: for families, the HDHP usually wins on cost, but the margin depends on how much you can fund the HSA, and the bad year asks for a lot of cash at once.

The question the spreadsheet can’t answer: can you pay the deductible?

Look at Ruben’s bad year again. The HDHP could ask for $9,000 out-of-pocket. Even with $4,750 in the HSA (his $4,000 plus the employer’s $750), that’s $4,250 more he’d need, fast. If that lands on a credit card at 24%, the HDHP’s paper savings disappear. That’s the cushion’s whole job. As our story about building a first $2,000 cushion puts it, the cushion is there to turn a disaster back into an inconvenience.

So the cheaper plan isn’t automatically the right one. Here’s how it fits the Middle Money Ladder:

  • The rule: your emergency cushion has to cover the HDHP’s deductible. Money sitting in your HSA counts toward that, because it’s there for exactly this. In our 12-month plan to escape paycheck to paycheck, Linda checks her health insurance deductible in month 7, the month she spends protecting what she’s built.
  • Steps 3 to 5 (budgeting, starter cushion, paying off debt): if you can’t cover the deductible from savings today, the PPO may be the safer choice until you reach step 6. A $2,000 starter cushion can handle Rhea’s $2,000 deductible. It can’t handle a $4,000 family deductible. If you do pick the HDHP while you’re on these steps, take every dollar of employer HSA money (like the 401(k) match, it’s part of your pay), and keep the HSA in cash, not investments.
  • Step 6 (full cushion of 3 to 6 months of essentials): once you’re here, a bad medical year won’t push you into debt, so the HDHP’s lower total cost is usually worth the risk. See how much should be in your emergency fund to size yours.
  • Step 7 (investing): this is when the HSA gets really powerful. Many HSAs let you invest the balance, and anything you don’t spend can grow tax-free for decades. But that’s step 7 money, after your cushion is full.

So what: the HDHP is often the cheaper plan, but only for someone who can absorb a bad year without borrowing.

Prefer to listen? In our podcast episode on HSA vs PPO, we walk through the three numbers that matter and why your emergency fund is part of your health plan.

Common mistakes at open enrollment

  • Comparing premiums only. A $960 premium difference means nothing until you add the deductible and the max.
  • Picking the HDHP and not funding the HSA. Then you get the high deductible without the tax break or the cushion. If you take the HDHP, set up a payroll contribution the same day.
  • Forgetting your employer’s HSA deposit. It’s real money, and it counts toward your annual limit.
  • Not checking the network. If your doctor is only in one plan, that can outweigh everything here.
  • Using last year’s numbers. Premiums and deductibles change every year.

Before you pick next year’s plan, check this year’s. In our video on money moves to make before December 31, Ana finds her family deductible already met and $640 left in her flexible spending account, so she books the care they had been putting off before both reset.

If your next year includes a big planned change like a new baby, start with how much to save before a baby, then run both plans with that year’s care in the formula. And if you’re choosing coverage because you’ve left a job, the COBRA question is covered in what to do with your money after a job loss.

Run your own numbers

Pick a goal and a date, and see how much to save each month to get there. Try the free savings goal calculator.

What to do this week

  1. Pull both plan summaries from your benefits portal: premium per paycheck, deductible, out-of-pocket max, coinsurance and any employer HSA deposit.
  2. Estimate a normal year. Look at last year’s claims or explanation-of-benefits statements and count visits, prescriptions and any planned procedures.
  3. Fill in the formula twice for each plan: normal year and bad year (out-of-pocket max). Use your own tax rate: your federal bracket plus 7.65% plus your state rate.
  4. Check your savings against the HDHP deductible. If your cushion plus any HSA balance can’t cover it, lean toward the PPO until you reach step 6.
  5. If you choose the HDHP, set your HSA payroll contribution now, ideally at least enough to cover the deductible over the year, and don’t enroll in a general FSA.

Frequently asked questions

Is a high-deductible health plan worth it?

For many healthy people, yes, because the lower premiums plus employer HSA money often beat the PPO even in a bad year, like Rhea’s $815 bad-year savings. For families with high, steady medical costs, it’s closer. Run the four-part formula for a normal year and a bad year, and only choose the HDHP if your savings can cover its deductible.

What happens to my HSA if I leave my job?

It stays yours. IRS Publication 969 says the HSA stays with you if you change employers or leave the workforce, and unused money carries over from year to year. You can keep using it for qualified medical expenses even if your next plan isn’t an HDHP; you just can’t add new contributions without HDHP coverage.

Can I use my HSA money for non-medical expenses?

You can, but it’s expensive before 65. Withdrawals not used for qualified medical expenses are taxed as income plus a 20% additional tax. After you turn 65 (or become disabled), the 20% additional tax goes away, though non-medical withdrawals are still taxed as income. Medical withdrawals stay tax-free at any age.

Can I have an HSA and an FSA at the same time?

Not a general health FSA. Being covered by a regular health FSA generally makes you ineligible to contribute to an HSA. A limited-purpose FSA, which covers things like dental and vision, or a post-deductible FSA, is allowed alongside an HSA.

Keep reading

Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.

The Middle Money Guy, illustrated host of The Middle Memo newsletter

THE MIDDLE MEMO

One money decision. One number worth knowing. One mindset shift. In your inbox every week, free, in about four minutes of reading.

No spam, no hype. Unsubscribe anytime.