Compare total compensation, not salary: take-home pay, 401(k) match, health premiums, HSA money, bonus, PTO and commute. In our example, a $78,000 job beats a $90,000 job by about $1,700 a year in hard dollars, and about $4,700 counting extra time off.
Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.
Subscribe to the channelIngrid is 33, single, and sitting in her car outside a coffee shop with two offer letters open on her phone. One says $78,000. The other says $90,000. She’s already picturing what an extra $12,000 a year would do for her.
Then she scrolls down. The $78,000 job matches 6% in the 401(k), pays most of her health insurance, puts money in an HSA, gives her 20 days off and lets her work from home three days a week. The $90,000 job has no match, an expensive health plan, 10 days off and a five-day commute.
Her gut says take the bigger number. Her spreadsheet is about to disagree.
The short answer: compare total compensation, not salary. Add up what each offer really puts in your pocket and your accounts in a year: take-home pay, the 401(k) match, what you pay for health insurance, HSA money, bonus, paid time off and commute costs. In Ingrid’s case, the $78,000 job comes out about $1,700 a year ahead in hard dollars, and about $4,700 ahead once you count the extra 10 days off. A $12,000 salary gap can disappear fast.
Why the salary gap is smaller than it looks
Start with what actually reaches your bank account. Using our standard estimate (single filer, 2026 federal brackets and standard deduction, 7.65% FICA, a flat 4% for state and local tax), the two salaries land like this:
- $78,000: about $5,049 a month take-home
- $90,000: about $5,712 a month take-home
That’s a difference of about $663 a month, or $7,962 a year. Not $12,000. Taxes take roughly a third of the raise before you ever see it. These are estimates (your pay stub is the real number), but the point holds for almost everyone: the gap on the offer letter is always bigger than the gap in your checking account.
So what: before you compare anything else, cut the salary difference down to its take-home size. That’s the number benefits have to beat.
The total compensation worksheet, line by line
Think of this as a total compensation calculator you run by hand: for each offer, add what you gain and subtract what it costs you.
1. The 401(k) match
Offer A matches 100% of what Ingrid puts in, up to 6% of pay. On $78,000, 6% is $4,680 a year of employer money. Offer B matches nothing. That single line wipes out more than half the take-home gap.
Two things to check: the formula (a “50% of 6%” match is only half as much, $2,340 here) and the vesting schedule, which decides when the match is really yours. Our 401(k) basics guide walks through both.
2. Health insurance premiums
Ask each employer what you’d pay per paycheck for the plan you’d actually pick. For reference, the KFF 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey (published October 2025, the latest as of this writing) found covered workers paid an average of $1,440 a year for single coverage and $6,850 a year for family coverage, out of total premiums averaging $9,325 and $26,993.
In our example, Offer A charges Ingrid $120 a month ($1,440 a year, right at the average). Offer B charges $375 a month ($4,500 a year). That’s a $3,060 difference. These are example premiums; use the real ones. And compare deductibles too: a cheap premium with a $6,000 deductible isn’t cheap if you use your insurance.
For a family, the gap can be much bigger. If Offer A charged the family average of $6,850 and Offer B charged $12,000 (again, example numbers), that one line would be worth $5,150 a year.
3. HSA employer contribution
If the plan is a high-deductible plan with a health savings account, some employers deposit money into it. Offer A puts in $750 a year (example). Per IRS Publication 969, employer HSA contributions aren’t included in your income, and they count toward your yearly limit, which for 2026 is $4,400 for self-only coverage and $8,750 for family coverage (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-19).
4. Paid time off
Price a day off at your daily pay: salary divided by 260 working days. At $78,000, that’s $300 a day. At $90,000, about $346. Offer A gives 20 days, Offer B gives 10. To match Offer A’s time off at Offer B, Ingrid would need 10 unpaid days, so we value the extra 10 days at $3,000 (10 × $300, using the lower rate to stay conservative). This is a “soft” number: it’s real value, but it never shows up as cash, so we keep it on its own line.
5. Bonus
Offer B has a 4% target bonus, $3,600 before tax. After tax, that’s about $2,389 by our estimate. Count only what’s realistic. Ask how often the bonus actually paid out at target the last few years, and if nobody can tell you, count half.
6. Commute and remote work
Offer A is hybrid: two days in the office. Offer B is five days, 25 miles each way, with paid parking. Ingrid estimates the extra three days a week cost her about $300 a month in gas, parking and wear on her car. That’s $3,600 a year (her estimate, not a standard figure). Add the hours, too: three extra round trips a week at about an hour each way is roughly 300 hours a year. You don’t have to put a dollar value on that, but you should notice it.
Ingrid’s worksheet: $78,000 vs. $90,000
Each row shows which offer comes out ahead on that line, and by how much per year.
| Line | Offer A ($78,000) | Offer B ($90,000) | Advantage per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take-home pay (estimate) | $60,583 | $68,545 | B +$7,962 |
| 401(k) match | $4,680 (6%) | $0 | A +$4,680 |
| Your health premium (single, example) | $1,440 | $4,500 | A +$3,060 |
| Employer HSA deposit (example) | $750 | $0 | A +$750 |
| Bonus, after tax (target) | $0 | $2,389 | B +$2,389 |
| Extra commute cost (her estimate) | $0 | $3,600 | A +$3,600 |
| Hard-dollar total | $12,090 in A’s favor | $10,351 in B’s favor | A +$1,739 |
| Extra PTO (10 days × $300) | $3,000 | $0 | A +$3,000 |
| Total with PTO | A +$4,739 |
The $78,000 job wins. By about $1,700 in cash and accounts, and about $4,700 counting time off.
One honest footnote: health premiums are often taken out before tax (check your pay stub), so the $3,060 premium gap costs Ingrid closer to $2,030 in take-home (it saves her about $1,030 in taxes at a roughly 34% combined rate). Even after that adjustment, Offer A still leads by about $700 in hard dollars. The lesson: you can’t know until you add up the lines.
So what: run the worksheet before you get attached to a number. If the higher salary still wins after every line, great, take it with a clear head. If you want to push the better offer higher, our guide to increasing your income covers negotiating. In our video on six ways to earn more, an outside offer of $19.50 an hour gets an auto parts worker’s current manager to counter with a raise and a promotion date.
Higher salary but worse benefits: is the new job really better?
Ingrid had two fresh offers. The more common version of this question is a recruiter calling about your current job. Saoirse is 41 and earns $70,000 with good benefits. A competitor offers her $76,000. A $6,000 raise sounds like a yes, until she puts a dollar value on what she’d give up.
Here are her lines, all per year. The take-home numbers use the same estimate as above; the benefits are example numbers, so swap in your own from each benefits summary.
- 401(k) match: her job matches 5% of pay ($3,500). The new one matches 50% of the first 4%, which is 2% of $76,000 ($1,520).
- Health premium: $90 a month now ($1,080 a year) vs. $310 a month at the new job ($3,720).
- Deductible: her plan’s deductible is $1,000, the new one’s is $4,500. She uses about $2,000 of care a year (physical therapy and a prescription). Now she pays the $1,000 deductible plus 20% of the next $1,000, so $1,200. On the new plan, all $2,000 falls under the deductible.
- PTO: 20 days now vs. 13 at the new job. Seven days at her daily pay ($70,000 divided by 260 is about $269) is worth about $1,883.
| Line | Current job ($70,000) | New offer ($76,000) | Advantage per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take-home pay (estimate) | $55,275 | $59,256 | New +$3,981 |
| 401(k) match | $3,500 | $1,520 | Current +$1,980 |
| Your health premium (example) | $1,080 | $3,720 | Current +$2,640 |
| Expected out-of-pocket care (example) | $1,200 | $2,000 | Current +$800 |
| Hard-dollar total | Current +$1,439 | ||
| Extra PTO (7 days × $269) | $1,883 | $0 | Current +$1,883 |
| Total with PTO | Current +$3,322 |
Check the math: $1,980 plus $2,640 plus $800 is $5,420 in benefits. Minus the $3,981 take-home gain, the “raise” leaves her about $1,439 a year behind in hard dollars, and about $3,322 behind counting time off. The pre-tax premium footnote above narrows that a little but doesn’t flip it. For the new job to really win, it would need to pay a little over $8,000 more than her current salary in hard dollars alone, not $6,000.
The deductible is the line people skip. If you rarely see a doctor, it may be worth close to zero to you. If you have a chronic condition or kids who get every bug at daycare, it can be worth more than the premium gap.
So what: before you say yes to a higher salary, put a price on every benefit you’d lose, including the deductible. Then use that number in the negotiation: “I’d be giving up about $5,400 a year in benefits” is a strong reason to ask for more.
Pension vs. higher salary
A traditional pension is the hardest benefit to price, and we’re not going to pretend there’s a simple formula. Instead, ask these questions:
- How long will you really stay? Pensions usually reward long careers. If you leave early, you may get little or nothing.
- What’s the vesting schedule? Find out exactly how many years until you have a right to any benefit.
- What’s the formula? Most are based on years of service and your pay near the end. Ask HR for a benefit estimate at 5, 10 and 20 years.
- Is there a 401(k) or 403(b) too? A pension plus a small match is a different deal than a pension alone.
Then compare honestly: if you’re likely to stay a long time, a pension can be worth a lot. If you’re likely to move on in three years, treat it as close to zero and decide on the rest of the worksheet. Either way, a pension doesn’t replace your own saving. The Middle Money Ladder still aims for about 15% of income into retirement once you reach step 7.
Is relocating for a raise worth it?
A raise in a pricier city can be no raise at all. Compare after-tax pay against the cost-of-living difference, starting with rent.
Say you earn $70,000 and pay $1,250 rent. A job in a bigger city offers $85,000, where a similar apartment costs $1,950. Here’s the monthly math:
| Monthly | Stay ($70,000) | Move ($85,000) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take-home pay (estimate) | $4,606 | $5,436 | +$830 |
| Rent (example) | $1,250 | $1,950 | $700 more |
| Other costs: groceries, insurance, parking (example) | +$150 | $150 more | |
| What’s left of the raise | about $20 a month less |
A $15,000 raise that leaves you $20 a month behind, before moving costs. In our video on what to do with a raise, Tyler’s $12,000 raise leaves him $50 a month worse off once a pricier truck and apartment move in. Worse, rent jumps from 27% of take-home to almost 36%, past our one-third red line (see how much rent you can afford). Moving can still make sense for career growth or a partner’s job. Just know what you’re buying.
So what: before you move for money, price your real rent and two or three other big costs in the new city, and run the take-home on both salaries. Thinking about the opposite trade, a lower salary in a cheaper place? See is moving to a cheaper state worth it.
Common mistakes
- Counting a bonus as guaranteed. Count what’s realistic, not what’s possible.
- Ignoring the deductible. A low premium can hide a big out-of-pocket bill.
- Forgetting vesting. A match you lose when you leave in year two isn’t worth $4,680 a year.
- Leaving the match on the table after you accept. If you pick the job with a match, set your contribution high enough to get all of it on day one. That’s step 3 of the Ladder, and it comes before your $2,000 starter cushion and before extra debt payments. In our video on taking action with money, Mia waits 14 months to sign up and misses about $2,200 of match.
Where this fits on the Ladder
A better offer helps every reader, but where the extra money goes depends on your step.
- Still carrying a credit card, car loan or other non-mortgage debt? Take the full match at the new job, keep your $2,000 starter cushion, and send the rest of the raise to your smallest debt first. Here’s how that order plays out in debt snowball vs. avalanche.
- Debt-free, but your full emergency fund isn’t built? Point the raise at 3 to 6 months of essential expenses. Here’s how to pick your number.
- Debt-free with a full cushion? You’re on step 7. Use the raise to get to about 15% of income for retirement, match first. Start with how to start investing.
Not sure which step you’re on? The Ladder quiz on the Middle Money Ladder page linked above will tell you in a couple of minutes.
Run your own numbers
Put in both salaries to see what the gap really looks like after taxes, then compare it with your benefits worksheet.
What to do this week
- Ask each employer for the benefits summary: 401(k) match formula and vesting, your premium for the plan you’d choose, the deductible, any HSA deposit, PTO days and bonus history.
- Estimate take-home for both salaries with your state’s tax rate, or use our raise calculator to see the after-tax difference.
- Fill in the worksheet: one row per line above, and total the hard dollars separately from PTO.
- Price your commute and, if you’re moving, your real rent in the new city.
- If the better offer is close, use your worksheet in the negotiation: a specific number is easier to ask for than “more.”
- Once you accept, set your 401(k) to get the full match from your first paycheck.
One money decision, one number worth knowing, one mindset shift. Free, every week.
Frequently asked questions
How do I calculate the value of a benefits package?
Add up the yearly dollar value of each benefit: the employer 401(k) match, what the employer covers of your health premium (or the difference in what you’d pay), any HSA deposit, a realistic bonus, and extra PTO at your daily pay (salary divided by 260). Subtract costs the job adds, like commuting. Then compare that total alongside take-home pay, not gross salary.
Should I take a lower-paying job with better benefits?
Often, yes, if the worksheet says so. In our example, a $78,000 job with a 6% match, cheaper health insurance and a hybrid schedule beat a $90,000 job by about $1,700 a year in hard dollars. Run your own numbers. Sometimes the higher salary still wins, and that’s fine too.
Is a higher salary worth worse benefits?
Only if the salary gap, after taxes, is bigger than the benefits you’d lose. Add up the match, the premium difference, the expected deductible and out-of-pocket costs, and PTO. In our example, a $6,000 raise from $70,000 to $76,000 left the worker about $1,400 a year behind once those lines were counted.
How much are good benefits worth in dollars?
Often several thousand dollars a year. A 5% match on $70,000 is $3,500, a cheaper health plan can save $2,000 to $3,000 in premiums (example numbers), and a lower deductible matters if you use care. Price each line from the benefits summary instead of guessing.
Is a pension better than a higher salary?
It depends mostly on how long you’ll stay. A pension can be very valuable over a long career, but it often pays little if you leave before you’re vested or after only a few years. Ask HR for benefit estimates at several years of service, and keep saving on your own either way.
How much more should a job pay to relocate?
Enough that your after-tax raise covers the higher rent and other costs with room to spare, plus your moving costs. In our example, a $15,000 raise from $70,000 to $85,000 was wiped out by $700 more in rent and $150 in other costs. Run the monthly math with real prices from the new city.
Keep reading
- 401(k) Basics: Matching, Contributions and Mistakes to Avoid
- Is $60K, $80K or $100K a Good Salary? What Each One Really Buys
- Got a Raise? Here’s What to Do Before You Spend It
Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.
