Big Decisions

Cash-Out Refinance vs. Home Equity Loan (and HELOC): Which Costs Less?

By · Updated October 28, 2026
The short answer

If your mortgage has a low rate, a cash-out refinance usually costs the most, because it reprices your whole mortgage, not just the new money. A home equity loan or HELOC leaves your first mortgage alone. For credit cards, only consider it after the spending stops, with a fast payoff plan.

Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.

Subscribe to the channel

Monica is 41, earns $95,000 a year, and has a kitchen that hasn’t been updated since the house was built. She owes $230,000 on a home worth about $400,000. That’s $170,000 of equity, and every lender wants to help her use it.

A loan officer pitches a cash-out refinance. A bank ad offers a home equity loan. Her credit union mentions a HELOC. All three put $40,000 in her hands. They don’t cost anywhere near the same.

Here’s the short answer. If your current mortgage has a low rate, a cash-out refinance is usually the most expensive way to borrow against your house, because it reprices your whole mortgage, not just the new money. A home equity loan or HELOC leaves your first mortgage alone. And if the money is for credit cards, moving that debt onto your house only makes sense after the spending has stopped, with a plan to pay it off fast.

The three options in plain words

  • Cash-out refinance. You replace your mortgage with a new, bigger one and take the difference in cash. Your old rate disappears.
  • Home equity loan. A second loan on top of your mortgage. You get a lump sum and repay it on a set schedule. The CFPB says it “usually has a fixed interest rate.”
  • HELOC (home equity line of credit). Also a second loan, but it works like a credit card secured by your house. You draw what you need during a draw period (often 10 years), then repay. The CFPB notes that HELOCs “usually have a variable interest rate, so your payments may change,” and payments are often much higher once the repayment period starts.

What all three have in common: your home is the collateral. If you can’t repay, the lender can foreclose. That’s the part the ads skip.

So what: the question isn’t “which loan gets me $40,000?” It’s “what happens to the debt I already have?”

How much equity can you borrow?

Lenders limit how much you can borrow as a share of your home’s value, called the loan-to-value ratio (LTV). For a conventional cash-out refinance on a one-unit primary home, both Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae’s eligibility matrix cap it at 80%. Fannie Mae also requires the existing mortgage to be at least 12 months old before a cash-out refinance.

For Monica: 80% of $400,000 is $320,000. Minus her $230,000 balance, she could take out up to about $90,000 with a cash-out refinance, before closing costs. For home equity loans and HELOCs, each lender sets its own cap on total borrowing against the house. Ask for it in writing.

So what: being allowed to borrow $90,000 says nothing about whether you should borrow $1.

Monica’s numbers: the kitchen

Monica’s mortgage is $230,000 at 3.5% with 25 years left. Her principal and interest payment is $1,151 a month, and if she just keeps paying, she’ll pay about $115,430 more in interest over those 25 years.

The rates below are examples for illustration, not current market rates. Check today’s quotes from real lenders.

Option A: cash-out refinance, $270,000 at an example 7% for 30 years

Her new payment would be $1,796 a month, $645 more than today. Total interest over 30 years: $376,674. She didn’t just borrow $40,000 at 7%. She also moved $230,000 from 3.5% to 7%, and added five years to the end of her mortgage.

Option B: home equity loan, $40,000 at an example 8.5% for 15 years

She keeps the 3.5% mortgage and adds a second payment of $394 a month. Combined: $1,545. Interest on the new loan: $30,901. If she paid it off in 5 years instead, the payment would be about $821 and the interest about $9,240.

Option C: HELOC at an example 9% variable

Many HELOCs only require interest during the draw period. On $40,000 at 9%, that’s $300 a month, and after 10 years she’d still owe the full $40,000. Then, repaying over 20 years at 9%, the payment jumps to about $360. Total interest that way: about $82,374. The rate is variable: at 11%, the interest-only payment alone would be about $367. Paid off in 5 years at a steady 9%: about $830 a month and $9,820 in interest.

Monthly payment (mortgage + new loan) Interest from here on Rate on the old $230,000
Today (no new loan) $1,151 $115,430 3.5%
A: Cash-out refi, 7%, 30 years $1,796 $376,674 7%
B: Home equity loan, 8.5%, 15 years $1,545 $146,331 3.5%
C: HELOC, 9%, interest-only 10 years then 20-year repayment $1,451 at first, then $1,511 $197,804 3.5%

The cash-out refinance costs about $230,343 more in interest than the home equity loan, for the same $40,000. Even on a 25-year term (about $1,908 a month, $302,491 in interest), it’s still roughly $156,000 more than Option B.

That’s the key insight. A cash-out refinance puts a higher rate on $270,000. A home equity loan puts it on $40,000. When your first mortgage is cheap, protect it. As our video on what to do with a raise puts it, a broke mind sees monthly payments and a rich mind sees totals.

The closing costs point the same way. The Federal Reserve’s refinancing guide says it’s “not unusual to pay 3 percent to 6 percent of your outstanding principal in refinancing fees.” On a $270,000 loan, that’s about $8,100 to $16,200. A home equity loan or HELOC is charged on a much smaller balance, and the CFPB’s HELOC brochure notes that some lenders waive some or all of a HELOC’s up-front costs, while closing costs on a cash-out refinance are “generally higher.”

One honest note on the kitchen itself: the Middle Money Ladder says no new monthly payments to keep up. The cheapest kitchen is the one you save for. A sinking fund of $800 a month gets you there in a little over four years with zero interest. If Monica does borrow, Option B is the one to look at.

The tax angle

According to IRS Publication 936, interest on a loan secured by your home is deductible only if the money is used to “buy, build, or substantially improve” the home that secures the loan. A kitchen remodel can qualify. Paying off credit cards doesn’t. And the deduction only helps if you itemize.

Monica’s numbers: $40,000 of credit cards

Now change one thing. The $40,000 isn’t for a kitchen. It’s credit card debt at an example 22%. That’s about $733 a month in interest alone. Our video on credit card minimum payments shows how slow that road is: paying only the minimum on $5,000 takes about 19 years.

If she pays $821 a month on the cards, it takes about 124 months (over 10 years) and $61,092 in interest. Move it to a 5-year home equity loan at an example 8.5%, same $821 payment, and it’s gone in 60 months with about $9,240 in interest. On paper, that saves about $51,850.

Same $40,000, $821 a month Time to pay off Interest What’s at risk if you can’t pay
Credit cards at 22% 124 months $61,092 Your credit
Home equity loan at 8.5%, 5 years 60 months $9,240 Your house
Home equity loan at 8.5%, 15 years ($394/mo) 180 months $30,901 Your house, for 15 years

Here’s what the math leaves out.

  • You turn unsecured debt into debt secured by your home. Miss card payments and your credit gets hurt. Miss home equity payments and you can lose the house.
  • It doesn’t fix the spending. Our podcast episode on paying off debt starts with this step: stop digging, and take the cards out of your wallet and your phone. The card limits are still there. If they fill up again, you now have $40,000 on the house and new card debt on top.
  • Stretching it out erases the win. The 15-year version costs $30,901 in interest. Rolling the cards into a 30-year cash-out refinance is worse: you’d be paying for old purchases until your 70s.

The Ladder view is simple. Step 5 says pay off all debt except the mortgage. A home equity loan used to clear cards is still step-5 debt, even though it’s attached to the house. Put every extra dollar on it and clear it in a few years, not 15. The full 401(k) match and the $2,000 starter cushion come first. If you’re not sure about the order, here’s how saving and debt payoff fit together.

Want to see your card payoff without touching the house? Run it here first:

When it can make sense

  • Your current mortgage rate is close to or above today’s rates, so a cash-out refinance doesn’t give up a cheap rate. (If you’re refinancing mainly for a lower rate, that’s a different question: see should I refinance? and the refinance calculator.)
  • The money goes into the house: a needed repair or an improvement you planned and priced.
  • For card debt: the spending has stopped for several months, you’ve tracked it, and you have a payoff date of 5 years or less.
  • You’ve closed or locked the cards you’re paying off, and you have an emergency fund so the next surprise doesn’t land on them.
  • The payment fits your budget even if a HELOC rate goes up 2 points.

When to walk away

  • The money is for lifestyle: a vacation, a car, a wedding, “catching up.”
  • You’d be giving up a 3% or 4% mortgage rate to borrow a fraction of the balance.
  • The cards are still growing. Fix the leak first. Start by tracking where the money goes.
  • Your job or income feels shaky.
  • The only way the payment works is a 15-year or 30-year term for consumer debt.

What to do this week

  1. Write down your mortgage balance, rate and years left. If your rate is low, cross a cash-out refinance off the list unless you have a strong reason.
  2. Get your home’s rough value and multiply by 0.8. Subtract what you owe. That’s your ceiling, not your target.
  3. If it’s for debt, list every card with balance, rate and minimum, and run the payoff in the calculator above before you apply for anything.
  4. Get written quotes from at least two lenders for a home equity loan and a HELOC. Compare the rate, every fee, and whether the HELOC is interest-only.
  5. Pick a payoff date of 5 years or less, and calculate the payment that gets you there. If it doesn’t fit your budget, don’t borrow.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between a cash-out refinance and a home equity loan?

A cash-out refinance replaces your mortgage with a bigger one at a new rate. A home equity loan is a second loan on top of your existing mortgage, so your first mortgage and its rate stay the same. With a low current rate, the home equity loan usually costs far less.

Home equity loan vs. HELOC: which is better?

A home equity loan gives you a lump sum, usually at a fixed rate with a set payoff date. A HELOC lets you draw as you go, usually at a variable rate, and may allow interest-only payments at first. The fixed loan is more predictable. A HELOC fits projects paid in stages, if you can handle a rate that moves.

Should I use home equity to pay off credit card debt?

Only if the spending has already stopped, the cards won’t fill up again, and you’ll pay the new loan off in a few years. It lowers the rate but puts your house on the line, so treat it as debt to clear fast, not as part of your mortgage.

How much are closing costs on a cash-out refinance?

The Federal Reserve says refinancing fees of 3% to 6% of the outstanding principal aren’t unusual. On a $270,000 loan, that’s about $8,100 to $16,200. Your Loan Estimate shows the real figure.

Is home equity loan interest tax deductible?

Per IRS Publication 936, only if the money is used to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, and only if you itemize. Interest on equity used for credit cards or a car isn’t deductible.

Keep reading

Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.

The Middle Money Guy, illustrated host of The Middle Memo newsletter

THE MIDDLE MEMO

One money decision. One number worth knowing. One mindset shift. In your inbox every week, free, in about four minutes of reading.

No spam, no hype. Unsubscribe anytime.