If payment, insurance, fuel and maintenance top 10% of your gross income, your car payment is too high. In order: pay extra on the loan, refinance at a lower rate without stretching the term, sell only if you can cover any gap in cash, and call your lender before you miss a payment.
Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.
Subscribe to the channelKevin is 33 and makes $65,000 a year. Every month, $433 leaves his checking account for a crossover he liked more on the lot than he does now. He owes $24,000 at 9%, with six years of payments to go. Last week he looked up what the car is worth: about $19,000.
So he can’t comfortably afford the payment, and he can’t cleanly sell the car either. He feels stuck. He isn’t. His problem has four exits, and some are a lot cheaper than others.
My car payment is too high. What can I do? Here’s the short answer. If all your car costs (payment, insurance, fuel, maintenance) run above 10% of your gross income, your car payment is too high. Your options, in order: keep the car and throw extra money at the loan, refinance to a lower rate without stretching the term, sell and buy something cheaper (covering any gap in cash, never rolling it into a new loan), or, if you truly can’t pay, call your lender before you miss a payment.
Is my car payment too high? The 10% test
The site’s car rule is 20/4/10: at least 20% down, a loan of 4 years or less, and total car costs under 10% of your gross income. We explain the whole rule in how much car you can afford. For a car you already own, only the 10% part matters right now.
Kevin’s gross pay is about $5,417 a month, so his car ceiling is about $542. His real costs:
- Payment: $433
- Insurance, fuel and maintenance: about $300
- Total: $733 a month, about 13.5% of gross
He’s about $190 a month over the line. On his estimated take-home of about $4,317 a month, the car eats roughly 17% of every paycheck. (That take-home is an estimate for a single filer; use your own pay stub.)
Here’s the quick version for other salaries, assuming the same $300 a month for insurance, fuel and maintenance:
| Gross salary | 10% for all car costs | Payment that fits |
|---|---|---|
| $50,000 | $417/mo | About $117 |
| $60,000 | $500/mo | About $200 |
| $65,000 | $542/mo | About $242 |
| $72,000 | $600/mo | About $300 |
| $85,000 | $708/mo | About $408 |
| $100,000 | $833/mo | About $533 |
If your payment sits well above the right column, the car is costing you progress somewhere else. The question is which exit gets you back under the line for the least money.
Option 1: Keep the car and attack the loan
The cheapest car is usually the one you already have. Selling costs you the gap, and buying again costs fees and taxes. So first, make this loan shorter.
Kevin’s loan as it stands: $24,000 at 9% for 72 months is $433 a month and $7,148 in interest. If he adds $150 a month to the principal, so he pays $583:
- The loan is gone in 50 months instead of 72, almost two years sooner.
- Total interest drops to $4,815, a savings of about $2,333.
- After one year, he owes about $18,964 instead of $20,840. That extra $1,876 of paydown is exactly what closes the gap between what he owes and what the car is worth.
Tell the lender to apply the extra to principal, not to next month’s payment, and check your first statement. Then automate it the day after payday. A transfer you plan to “send when you can” won’t happen.
So what: extra principal doesn’t lower your monthly bill today, but it ends the bill years sooner and gets you right-side up faster, which opens up every other option.
Option 2: Refinance, but watch the term
If your credit has improved, or you took dealer financing without shopping around, a bank or credit union may offer a lower rate. Here’s Kevin’s $24,000 balance under a few choices, using an example new rate of 6.5%:
| Choice | Monthly payment | Months | Total interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do nothing (9%, 72 months) | $433 | 72 | $7,148 |
| Do nothing, plus $150 extra | $583 | 50 | $4,815 |
| Refinance 6.5%, 72 months | $403 | 72 | $5,048 |
| Refinance 6.5%, 60 months | $470 | 60 | $4,175 |
| Refinance 6.5%, keep paying $433 | $433 | 67 | $4,621 |
| Refinance 6.5%, pay $583 | $583 | 47 | $3,231 |
| Refinance 6.5%, 84 months | $356 | 84 | $5,936 |
| Refinance 8%, 84 months | $374 | 84 | $7,422 |
The best rows combine a lower rate with the same or shorter term. Refinancing at 6.5% and still paying $583 a month gets Kevin out in under four years with about $3,900 less interest than doing nothing.
The trap is the bottom of the table. Refinancing gets sold as “lower your payment,” and the easiest way to lower a payment is to add years. Stretch to 84 months and the payment falls to $356, but you pay for this car until year seven, you stay upside down longer, and if the rate drop is small (the 8% row), you pay more interest than if you’d done nothing. A lower payment is not the same thing as a cheaper loan. As our video on why raises disappear puts it, a broke mind sees monthly payments, and a rich mind sees totals.
Before you refinance, check for a prepayment penalty on your current loan, the new lender’s fees, and the total interest, not just the payment. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau notes that a prepayment penalty in your current agreement can add a fee when you refinance.
So what: refinance for the rate, not the payment. Keep the term the same or shorter, and if you can, keep paying your old amount.
Run your own loan through different rates and terms here:
Option 3: Sell it and drive something cheaper
Sometimes the car itself is the problem: a big insurance bill, bad mileage, or a payment no realistic extra amount can fix. If you’re upside down, deal with the gap first.
Kevin owes $24,000. The car is worth about $19,000. If he sells, the buyer’s money pays off $19,000 and Kevin still owes the lender $5,000. That $5,000 has to come from somewhere.
Ways to cover the gap, best to worst:
- Cash you’ve saved for it. Not your $2,000 starter cushion. Build the gap money separately, then sell. Our podcast on the starter cushion calls that $2,000 your spare tire: it’s for something you didn’t choose, that you need and that can’t wait.
- Pay it down first. Use Option 1 for a year or so until the gap is small or gone, then sell.
- A small, short loan for the gap. A $5,000 credit union loan at an example 10% for 24 months is about $231 a month and $537 in interest. It’s still debt, but it’s visible and it ends.
Be honest with the math, though. If Kevin borrows the gap at $231 a month and finances a $9,000 used car at 9% for 36 months ($286 a month), he’s paying $517, more than his current $433. Selling only helps if the gap is covered with cash, or the cheaper car saves a lot on insurance and fuel. For Kevin, right now, Option 1 or 2 wins.
Never roll negative equity into the next loan
The dealer will offer: “We’ll pay off your old loan.” Usually the $5,000 just gets added to your new loan. The CFPB warns that rolling your old balance into a new loan makes the new loan more expensive and suggests waiting to trade in if you’re underwater.
Here’s what it looks like. Kevin trades for a $15,000 car and rolls in the $5,000. He finances $20,000 at 9% for 60 months: $415 a month and $4,910 in interest. The same $15,000 car on its own would be $311 a month and $3,683 in interest. His payment drops by only $18, and he starts the new loan $5,000 upside down again. In our video on fixing a car payment that’s too high, the dealer offers Tyler a lower payment by rolling his negative equity into an 84-month loan, which the video calls digging the same hole deeper with a nicer shovel.
So what: selling is a real option only when you can close the gap without new long-term debt. If you can’t, pay down first.
Option 4: If you can’t make the payment
If a job loss, a medical bill or a cut in hours means you can’t make next month’s payment, the order of moves changes.
Call the lender before you miss a payment. The CFPB’s guidance on what to do if you can’t make your car payments says to contact your lender or servicer as soon as possible. Options can include an affordable payment plan, changing your due date, or pausing payments through forbearance (often called a deferment). Ask how interest is handled during the pause and where the skipped payments go, usually to the end of the loan. Get the agreement in writing.
Know what repossession costs. If the lender takes the car, it sells it, usually for less than you owe. According to the CFPB, you may still owe the difference plus repossession fees, and a repossession can stay on your credit reports for up to seven years.
Voluntary surrender is still repossession. Handing the keys back yourself doesn’t erase the loan. The CFPB’s 2025 report on auto repossessions treats voluntary surrenders as repossessions and found that 94% of the vehicles lenders sold in its data ended with a deficiency balance the borrower could be asked to repay.
If you’ve lost income, our money plan for losing your job covers which bills to protect first.
Is it worth paying off a car loan early?
Yes, in the right order. Our podcast on buying back your paycheck explains the payoff: a paid-off car payment works like a permanent raise of that amount. On the Middle Money Ladder, a car loan is step 5 debt. Before you send extra money to it, you should be getting your full 401(k) match (step 3) and have a $2,000 starter cushion in a separate savings account (step 4). Then every extra dollar goes to debt, car included. If you also carry credit cards, those usually come first because the rate is higher; see debt snowball vs. avalanche to pick an order, and our guide to the right order if you’re unsure whether you’re ready.
One check before you start: prepayment penalties. The CFPB says your contract and state law decide whether you can pay off early without a fee, and some states prohibit these penalties for certain loans. Check your contract or ask the lender.
What to do this week
- Add up your real monthly car cost (payment, insurance, fuel, maintenance) and divide it by your gross monthly pay. Over 10% means it’s too high.
- Pull your loan statement: balance, rate, months left. Look up what the car is worth and write down the gap, if any.
- Read your contract for a prepayment penalty.
- Get one refinance quote from a credit union or bank. Compare total interest at the same or a shorter term, not just the payment.
- Once you’re getting your full 401(k) match and have your $2,000 starter cushion, set up an automatic extra principal payment, even $50, the day after payday.
- If you can’t make next month’s payment, call your lender this week, before the due date.
One money decision, one number worth knowing, one mindset shift. Free, every week.
Frequently asked questions
Can I lower my car payment without refinancing?
Not by much. A lender may let you skip a payment or move your due date, but the monthly payment only drops if the loan changes: a refinance, a longer term (which costs more interest) or a smaller balance. Extra payments on principal end the loan sooner but usually don’t lower the monthly payment, so ask your lender how it applies them.
Is there a calculator for paying off a car loan early with extra payments?
Yes. Enter your car loan in the debt payoff calculator with your extra monthly amount. It shows your new payoff date and the interest you save.
How do I get out of an upside-down car loan?
Usually the cheapest way is to keep the car and pay extra principal until you owe less than it’s worth. An extra $150 a month cut Kevin’s balance by about $1,876 more in the first year. If you must sell, cover the gap in cash or with a small short loan, never by rolling it into the next car.
Is it smart to refinance a car loan?
It can be, if you get a lower rate and keep the same or a shorter term. Refinancing Kevin’s $24,000 from 9% to 6.5% over 60 months saves about $2,973 in interest compared with doing nothing. Stretching to 84 months lowers the payment but can cost more overall.
How can I pay off my car loan faster?
Add a fixed extra amount to every payment and tell the lender to apply it to principal. On a $24,000 loan at 9%, an extra $150 a month turns 72 payments into 50 and saves about $2,333 in interest.
Can you pay more than your monthly car payment?
Usually, yes. Tell the lender to apply the extra to principal, not to next month’s payment, and check your next statement to make sure it did. First read your contract for a prepayment penalty: the CFPB says your contract and state law decide whether you can pay early without a fee.
Does voluntary repossession hurt your credit?
Yes. It’s still a repossession: you can owe the gap between the sale price and your balance, plus fees, and it can stay on your credit reports for up to seven years. Ask your lender about a payment plan or forbearance first.
Keep reading
- How Much Car Can I Afford?
- Debt Snowball vs. Avalanche: Which Pays Off Faster?
- What to Do With Extra Money: Bonus, Tax Refund or $10,000
Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.
