For college money, a 529 is usually better: tax-free growth for school, you keep control, and it counts lightly for aid. A custodial (UTMA/UGMA) account fits money meant for your child for any purpose, but it becomes theirs at 18 or 21 depending on your state.
Like the math? New money videos on YouTube. No hype, no jargon.
Subscribe to the channelRafael is 34, earns $85,000, and his son Theo is six weeks old. Theo can’t hold his head up yet, but he already has a fan club with opinions. A coworker says “open a 529, obviously.” Rafael’s brother says “skip the 529, open a brokerage account in the kid’s name so the money isn’t locked up.” And Rafael’s parents just called: they want to give Theo $5,000.
So Rafael is staring at two account types he’s never used and a check that’s coming either way. Which one gets the money? Both?
Here’s the short answer. For college money, a 529 plan is usually the better home: growth is tax-free for school, you stay in control, and it counts lightly for financial aid. A custodial account (UTMA or UGMA) fits money meant for your child for any purpose, with one big catch: it legally becomes your child’s to control at 18 or 21, depending on your state. Many families use a 529 as the main account and add a custodial account or custodial Roth IRA only for specific money.
529 vs. UTMA: the side-by-side comparison
A 529 plan is a state-sponsored education account you own, with your child as beneficiary. A custodial account is a regular investment account that belongs to your child, which you manage as custodian until they come of age. UTMA and UGMA are two versions of the law; your state decides which one you get.
| 529 plan | Custodial account (UTMA/UGMA) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who controls it | You, the account owner, for as long as it exists | You as custodian until the age your state sets (18 or 21), then your child |
| Whose money it is | Yours, earmarked for the beneficiary | Your child’s, from day one. The gift can’t be taken back |
| Taxes on growth | No federal tax on earnings used for qualified education expenses | Taxed as your child’s income, with the kiddie tax above $2,700 of unearned income (2026) |
| What it can pay for | College, trade school, K-12 tuition up to $20,000 a year, some credentials, limited student loan payments | Anything that benefits the child, and anything at all once they take control |
| Financial aid (FAFSA) | Parent asset, if a parent owns it | Always a student asset |
| If plans change | Switch beneficiary, roll some to a Roth IRA, or withdraw (earnings taxed plus 10%) | No penalty, but the money stays your child’s |
The so what: the 529 trades flexibility for tax savings and control. The custodial account does the opposite. Pick based on what the money is for.
How each account is taxed
529 plans
Contributions aren’t deductible on your federal return, but earnings grow tax-free and come out tax-free for qualified education expenses, per IRS Topic 313 (updated September 24, 2026). After the 2025 tax law, K-12 expenses include tuition, curriculum, books, outside tutoring, test fees and certain educational therapies, capped at $20,000 per year across all of a child’s 529s (it was $10,000 before December 31, 2025). Check your state plan’s website for any state tax benefit.
Take money out for something else and the earnings part is taxed as income, plus a 10% additional tax, according to IRS Publication 970. Your contributions come back tax-free.
Custodial accounts
Dividends and gains are your child’s income. For 2026, IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 sets the kiddie tax amount at $1,350: the first $1,350 of unearned income is covered by the child’s standard deduction, the next $1,350 is taxed at the child’s rate, and above $2,700 the excess is taxed at the parents’ rate (IRS Topic 553).
For most families, that’s not a big problem. A $5,000 account paying, say, $150 a year in dividends (an example, not a forecast) is nowhere near $1,350.
Will your kids get control of the money at 18?
With a custodial account, yes. FINRA puts it plainly: depositing assets into a UTMA or UGMA account “represents an irrevocable transfer from the donor to the beneficiary,” and the custodianship generally ends at the age of majority or another age set by state law. Depending on your state, that’s 18 or 21. Then the money is theirs, and FINRA notes it can be used for any purpose. College, a car, a trip. Their call.
With a 529, no. The owner keeps control. Theo will never be able to cash out his 529 for a motorcycle, because it’s Rafael’s account. If Theo doesn’t need it, Rafael can switch the beneficiary to another family member with no income tax consequences.
The so what: if an 18-year-old with full access to the money makes you nervous, that money belongs in a 529.
Financial aid: why the owner matters
The 2026-27 FAFSA form is clear: a 529 is reported as a parent asset when the student reports parent information, UGMA and UTMA accounts are always the student’s asset, and retirement accounts, including non-education IRAs, aren’t reported at all.
In the federal Student Aid Index guide for 2026-27, 20% of a dependent student’s net assets counts toward what the family is expected to pay. Parent assets get an asset protection allowance first and a much lower conversion. Same dollars, smaller aid hit in a parent-owned 529.
Rafael’s plan: when “both” makes sense
Before any account, ask: is this your money or someone else’s?
On the Middle Money Ladder, your own monthly money for your kids’ college starts once every debt except the mortgage is paid off (step 5). Keep taking your full 401(k) match the whole time. From there, college savings can run alongside your 3 to 6 month cushion and your 15% for retirement. The biggest gain for your family is having no debt: every dollar you stop paying in interest is a dollar that can go to their future. Just never trade your retirement for their tuition. Your kids can borrow or get aid for college. Nobody lends you money for retirement. Our walk through all nine Ladder steps shows where each one fits, and our video on when to start a college account follows Dana, a mom with nothing saved, through this exact order. If you still have debt, the order that actually works comes first. Our video on credit card minimum payments sums up why: no investment reliably pays you 22% a year, but a credit card reliably charges you that.
Rafael checks his list. His only debt is the mortgage, he has five months of essentials in high-yield savings, and he puts 15% into his 401(k), including the match. He’s debt-free, so he’s clear. His split:
- His own money: $150 a month into a 529 he owns, with Theo as beneficiary. (How much to aim for is its own question: how much to save for college.)
- His parents’ $5,000: also into the 529, because they want it to help with school.
- A custodial account: not yet. Only if no-strings money shows up and he’s fine with Theo controlling it at 18 or 21.
Theo, born in 2026, may also qualify for a Trump account. The IRS says U.S. citizen children with a valid Social Security number born from January 1, 2025, through December 31, 2028, can get a $1,000 pilot contribution by filing Form 4547. Most contributions are capped at $5,000 a year and the money generally stays in until the year the child turns 18, per IRS guidance from December 2025. Details are in investing for kids.
Grandparents want to give $5,000: how to invest it without tax problems
A $5,000 gift is far below the limit that matters. For 2026, the first $19,000 of gifts from one person to another isn’t a taxable gift (Rev. Proc. 2025-32). It’s per giver, per recipient, so each grandparent can give $5,000 to each grandchild with room to spare.
Then match the account to the wish:
- “It’s for college.” The 529. Tax-free for school, you control it, parent asset on the FAFSA.
- “It’s for them, whatever they choose.” A custodial account. At $5,000 the kiddie tax is unlikely to apply. Tell the grandparents the child gets control at 18 or 21.
- “We want it to grow for decades.” If the child has a job, a custodial Roth IRA (next section).
Gift money isn’t yours, so the Ladder doesn’t hold it back. You can invest it for your kids at any step.
Custodial Roth IRA: can your 15-year-old have one?
Yes, if he earns money. A Roth IRA has no minimum age. It requires taxable compensation, and the limit is the lesser of the annual cap or what he earned, per IRS Publication 590-A. For 2026, the annual cap is $7,500. A parent opens it as custodian.
Fast forward: Theo is 15 and earns $4,200 lifeguarding over the summer. His limit is $4,200, not $7,500. Allowance doesn’t count; real work does, so keep a record of who paid him, when and how much. And a Roth IRA isn’t reported as an asset on the FAFSA.
Scholarship leftovers: what to do with the 529 money
Say Theo, now 18, wins a $10,000-a-year scholarship, and his 529 holds $40,000: $24,000 Rafael put in and $16,000 of growth. His options:
- Spend it on other qualified costs. If the scholarship covers only tuition, housing, books and required equipment can still come from the 529.
- Withdraw up to the scholarship amount, penalty-free. Pub 970 waives the 10% additional tax up to the tax-free scholarship amount, but earnings are still taxed. Of a $10,000 withdrawal, about $4,000 is earnings ($10,000 x $16,000 / $40,000). That $4,000 is taxable, but the $400 additional tax goes away.
- Save it for grad school or a credential later.
- Change the beneficiary to a sibling, a cousin or even Rafael, with no income tax.
- Roll some into Theo’s Roth IRA. Per IRS Topic 313, the 529 must be open at least 15 years, the money must have been in more than 5 years, it moves trustee-to-trustee, it counts against Theo’s annual Roth limit, and there’s a $35,000 lifetime cap. Opening the 529 while Theo is a baby starts that 15-year clock.
Topic 313 also allows up to $10,000 in lifetime student loan payments. Leftover 529 money has good exits.
Run your own numbers
See what regular deposits could grow to over time. Try the free compound interest calculator.
What to do this week
- Find your Ladder step. If you still have debt besides the mortgage, park your own kid savings plans and pay it off first. Our podcast overview of the Middle Money Ladder walks through all nine steps in order.
- Sort the money by source: yours, gifts, your child’s earnings. Each has a different best home.
- Compare your state’s 529 plan with one or two others: fees, investment options, state tax benefit.
- Ask gift-givers what the money is for, then pick the 529 or a custodial account.
- If your child was born 2025 to 2028, file Form 4547 for the Trump account pilot deposit.
- If your teen has a job, track the earnings and look at a custodial Roth IRA.
One money decision, one number worth knowing, one mindset shift. Free, every week.
Frequently asked questions
What happens to a 529 if my child doesn’t go to college?
Change the beneficiary to another family member tax-free, use it for trade school or a credential, roll up to $35,000 over time into the child’s Roth IRA if the rules are met, or withdraw it. A non-qualified withdrawal means the earnings are taxed plus a 10% additional tax; your contributions come back tax-free.
Can I take money back out of a custodial account?
Not for yourself. The gift is irrevocable and the money belongs to your child. As custodian, you can spend it only for your child’s benefit, and you must hand it over at the age your state sets.
Can I use a 529 for private school?
Yes. Starting in 2026, up to $20,000 a year per child can go to K-12 tuition and related costs like curriculum, tutoring and test fees. Every dollar spent early is a dollar not growing for college.
Does a custodial Roth IRA hurt financial aid?
The balance doesn’t. The FAFSA leaves retirement accounts, including IRAs, out of reportable assets.
Keep reading
- Investing for Kids: When to Start and How Much It Can Grow
- How Much to Save for College
- How Much Do I Need to Retire?
Education, not financial advice. The numbers here are examples; talk to a licensed professional about your own situation. Some links may be sponsored or affiliate links; see our disclosure.
